FitX scraps the annual contract, but automatic renewal stays

FitX scraps the annual contract, but automatic renewal stays

I looked at attendance over the last twelve weeks at one of the gyms I own a stake in, counting only members who have been paying for at least three months. There are 157 of them and on average they come twice a week, a figure that pleases until you notice that 60 of them, 38%, turn up less than once a week while 13 have not been seen at all. It is a box, as gyms are called in CrossFit, where almost everyone has paid up front for a membership of about a year that does not renew itself when it expires, and we set it up that way because anyone who wants to keep coming knows perfectly well that they have to renew.

On Tuesday Handelsblatt, Germany's leading business daily, reported the opposite move. FitX, which the paper describes as the country's second-largest gym chain, has dropped the annual contract, new customers included, who can now cancel month by month while paying €29 on top of the joining fee, with no discounts. The company says it is the first large chain to do so, while its chief executive, Markus Vancraeyenest, explains that people who train regularly do not cancel and that long contracts have damaged the industry's image. British readers may find the novelty relative, since PureGym and The Gym Group have sold monthly memberships with no contract for years.

The tie FitX is giving up was already shorter than it looks, though. Since 1 March 2022 German consumer contract law has required that, once the initial term is over, a gym membership continues indefinitely and can be cancelled monthly, so FitX's contract only bound customers for their first twelve months. Then on 16 July the Federal Court of Justice, Germany's highest civil court, ruled for the federation of consumer associations in a case brought against FitX itself. On the page where members confirmed their online cancellation, the chain had placed an orange button over a photo of someone working out, inviting them to pause the contract instead of ending it, whereas according to the judges that page must serve only to cancel.

What remains is the thing a contract never did and that keeps working without one. In 2006 Stefano DellaVigna and Ulrike Malmendier, two economists then at Berkeley and Stanford, published in the American Economic Review a study that became a classic on its title alone, Paying Not to Go to the Gym. They had followed almost 8,000 members of three American clubs for three years and found that people who chose the monthly membership, which renewed automatically there, let an average of 2.31 months pass between their last visit and cancelling, with one member in five taking at least four. The most telling figure was another one, though. Those monthly customers, free to leave whenever they liked, were 17% more likely to still be members after a year than those who had signed an annual contract, which in those clubs expired and had to be renewed by hand. The freedom to leave kept more people in than the tie did, because leaving took an action while staying only required doing nothing.

Read alongside these numbers, Vancraeyenest's line also works the other way round, because for a few months even those who have stopped training do not cancel. For a chain charging €29 a month this is no detail, since a model at that price also rests on a sizeable share of members not turning up, otherwise the floors would not cope at peak hours. FitX can therefore afford to remove the paper cage because the one that matters stays where it was, namely the direct debit that renews itself and that nobody has to remember to authorise. The tie does not disappear, it moves, from the contract to the habit of doing nothing.

The box I own a stake in has deliberately made the mirror-image choice, keeping the annual membership paid in advance but giving up inertia. Every year anyone who wants to continue has to renew with an explicit act, so a member who has stopped coming simply does not renew. Of those who let a prepaid membership lapse over the past three years, thirteen out of eighteen kept training until the end, while of the 23 members who left over the same period only two paid anything after their last visit. These are small numbers that prove nothing on their own, but they describe a model that earns from people who decide rather than from people who forget. The American study shows what that choice costs, because a renewal that has to be asked for every year loses more customers than a payment that runs by itself.

Even with us, though, more than one member in three comes less than once a week, something no form of contract has any grip on. I have never believed that a signed commitment changes the way a person trains, yet motivation campaigns do not deliver what they promise either. In December 2021 Katy Milkman, a behavioural scientist at the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania, published in Nature, together with some thirty researchers from fifteen American universities, an experiment on more than 61,000 members of 24 Hour Fitness, a large American chain, who were offered 54 different four-week digital programmes made up mostly of reminders and small incentives. Almost half the programmes raised weekly visits by between 9% and 27%, but only 8% left an effect that could still be measured once the programme was over. The most effective one gave a tiny reward to people who came back after missing a workout, which means it worked on returning rather than on joining.

Returning is precisely what a low-cost chain cannot follow person by person, whereas in a box someone usually notices if you have been missing for two weeks. A question remains, one that FitX's numbers will answer better than I can once they arrive, and it is whether removing the contract will make the industry more honest or will simply move the tie to a place where no court will ever go looking for it.